Eugenic Feminism: Reproductive Nationalism in the United States and India

By Asha Nadkarni

Asha Nadkarni contends that every time feminists lay declare to citizenship in accordance with women’s organic skill to “reproduce the state” they're partaking in a eugenic project—sanctioning copy by means of a few and prohibiting it through others. using quite a lot of assets from the us and India, Nadkarni exhibits how the exclusionary impulse of eugenics is embedded in the phrases of nationalist feminism.

Nadkarni finds connections among U.S. and Indian nationalist feminisms from the overdue 19th century in the course of the Seventies, demonstrating that either demand feminist citizenship headquartered at the reproductive physique because the starting place of the state. She juxtaposes U.S. and Indian feminists (and antifeminists) in provocative and effective methods: Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s utopian novels regard eugenic copy as a necessary type of nationwide creation; Sarojini Naidu’s political speeches and poetry posit liberated Indian ladies as energetic brokers of a nationalist and feminist modernity predating that of the West; and Katherine Mayo’s 1927 mom India warns white U.S. ladies that Indian replica is a “world menace.” moreover, Nadkarni strains the refashioning of the icon Mother India, first in Mehboob Khan’s 1957 movie Mother India and Kamala Markandaya’s 1954 novel Nectar in a Sieve, and later in Indira Gandhi’s self-fashioning as mom India throughout the Emergency from 1975 to 1977.

By uncovering an understudied heritage of feminist interactivity among the USA and India, Eugenic Feminism brings new intensity either to our realizing of the complex courting among the 2 countries and to modern feminism.

Show description

Quick preview of Eugenic Feminism: Reproductive Nationalism in the United States and India PDF

Best Feminism books

The Beauty Myth: How Images of Beauty Are Used Against Women

The bestselling vintage that redefined our view od the connection among good looks and feminine identification. In modern global, ladies have extra energy, criminal attractiveness, good fortune than ever ahead of. along the glaring growth of the women's flow, notwithstanding, author and journalist Naomi Wolf is stricken through a unique type of social keep watch over, which, she argues, may perhaps end up simply as restrictive because the conventional picture of homemaker and spouse.

The Female Eunuch

The ebook of Germaine Greer's the feminine Eunuch in 1970 was once a landmark occasion, elevating eyebrows and ire whereas making a surprise wave of popularity in ladies all over the world with its steadfast statement that sexual liberation is the most important to women's liberation. at the present time, Greer's searing exam of the oppression of girls in modern society is either a major old checklist of the place we have been and an incredibly suitable treatise on what nonetheless continues to be completed.

The Color Purple

Now a Broadway musical  Winner of the Pulitzer Prize  Winner of the nationwide booklet Award   released to unparalleled acclaim, the colour pink verified Alice Walker as a tremendous voice in sleek fiction. this can be the tale of 2 sisters—one a missionary in Africa and the opposite a baby spouse dwelling within the South—who maintain their loyalty to and belief in one another throughout time, distance, and silence.

Feminism, Sexuality, and the Return of Religion (Indiana Series in the Philosophy of Religion)

Feminist conception and reflections on sexuality and gender hardly ever make touch with modern continental philosophy of faith. the place all of them come jointly, inventive and transformative considering happens. In Feminism, Sexuality, and the go back of faith, the world over well-known students take on advanced questions provoked through the usually stormy intersection of those strong forces.

Extra resources for Eugenic Feminism: Reproductive Nationalism in the United States and India

Show sample text content

In mobilizing the figure of the “black rapist,” a phantom that Ida B. Wells used to be within the means of very publicly denouncing as apocryphal, Gilman was once absolutely leveraging the race politics of her time and overwriting the true histories of sexual violence opposed to African American girls and the lynching of African American males. finally, Gilman publishes ladies and Economics in basic terms 4 years after Wells’s British excursions (in 1893 and 1894) had made lynching a part of the nationwide dialog. 33 although more often than not Gilman’s perspectives on African americans are complex, her stance on lynching and the specter of sexual violence it supposedly comprises is published in a 1912 article, “Should girls Use Violence?

Seventy four Naidu’s connection with “gutters” and “drains” surely remembers her mentor Gandhi’s description of Mayo’s ebook and in addition calls awareness to Mayo’s selective view of India. As such, Naidu indicates, Mayo’s muckraking might be brushed off as an unimportant “stunt” that seeks in basic terms to divert a distractible U. S. public from the true factor to hand: India’s freedom. to be able to carry India’s lofty message to the U. S. public, Naidu forwards herself as an interpreter among cultures. As she recounts in her Presidential tackle to the All-India Women’s convention (AIWC) in Bombay in January 1930: 124 “ wor l d m enace” It was once as a lady of this historic race with its millennia of expertise that during my travels final yr I checked out the lives of these baby nations of Europe and people kindergarten nations of the US.

Stands because the in basic terms potent competitor to China for the religion and following of the hundreds of thousands of uncommitted and stressed humans. ”78 India’s nonalignment awarded an issue, besides the fact that; notwithstanding from Nehru’s standpoint nonalignment was once simply that—a refusal to develop into a pawn in U. S. –Soviet chilly conflict politics—to the USA it gave the impression of veiled help for communism. hence the us was hoping that modernization and improvement could “channel the nonaligned and nationalist aspirations in [India, Egypt and Ghana] in additional basically pro-Western instructions.

Out of the country imperialism (1898) and finishing with Indira Gandhi’s interval of Emergency rule (1975–77). Eugenic Feminism is for that reason framed by means of nationwide crises: the first entailed by means of the last of the frontier and the funneling of U. S. imperial pursuits in another country, the second one entailed by way of the betrayal of Indian nationalism within the Emergency. I commence and finish with diversified moments of nationwide obstacle, at junctures the place the very that means of the country is up for grabs, so that it will imagine via how nationalist feminism reimagines itself with regards to the kingdom in instances of upheaval.

Girls have been basically checked out as elements of social welfare programmes and never of improvement. . . . Why used to be this so and the way used to be it that once women’s very seen presence and participation within the nationwide fight for freedom . . . girls as girls have been so missed? —Nirmala Buch, “State Welfare coverage and girls, 1950–1975” To many the years after Independence appeared the location of a critical setback for feminists. . . . within the fifties and sixties, for this reason, there has been a lull in feminist campaigning. —Radha Kumar, The background of Doing D e s p i t e t h e f o r m a l e q ua l i t y granted to ladies via the Indian structure and the continuing visibility of elite nationalist feminists in politics, the many years following Indian independence were classified the “‘silent interval’ of the women’s move.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 17 votes